Sound and Vision- Robin 2, Bilston, Wolverhampton Uk 4/8/23

This is the fourth Bowie tribute I have seen this year so I am starting to feel as much a tribute expert as I am a Bowie fan.

The Robin 2 in Bilston Wolverhampton is a great live venue with a long tradition of original and tribute bands and a loyal and knowledgeable audience, a significant number of whom are a “walk up”

S&V perform as a seven piece with Chris Burke on lead vocals, tall, blonde, lean and imposing, he isn’t a Bowie clone but convinces as a front man .  Jeff John in short frock coat and ruffle neck white blouse  looks like he is auditioning for a Spandeau Ballet tribute on lead  guitar, John Wilmott plays Bass, Colin Elward is hidden at the back on Keyboards, with a similarly shy Simon Harry on Rhythm Guitar, Gareth Addey is on Drums and Mike Davies  on Saxophone.

The sax is a problem. As soon as I saw it I knew that they would play “Sorrow”, “Young Americans” , “Absolute Beginners” and “the Man Who Sold the World” ,what I did not expect was for it to appear in every song to the extent that at times I felt as though I was watching a Madness tribute. The introduction to ”Ashes to Ashes”  was ruined by an obtrusive lead sax part. Davies play well, but his omnipresence is a musical misfire.

Invariably I am charitable to most live performers, and tribute acts. But when these acts are asking £20 (tonight), £30, sometimes more, the stakes are raised. I would expect to pay £10 for a cover band, if I am paying over twice that, my expectations are similarly raised.

S&V came on at 8.30pm and finished at 11pm with a half hour break so the venue could take some more beer money! It was a game of two halves, the first was poor,  the second was much better.

Setlist

Moonage Daydream

Sorrow

Changes

The man who sold the world

Oh You pretty things

Starman

Life on mars

Boys keep swinging

Blue jean

Queen Bitch

Hang onto yourself

Ziggy Stardust

The main problem was not the song choice, it was the running order which clunked and stuttered.  Even the usually reliable “Starman” failed to prompt a sing a long, “Boys” was leaden, and “Mars” had an odd original keyboard intro.

“Moonage Daydream” is one of David’s very best songs and a live cracker. It was totally misplaced as an opener before the crowd, and band, were  warmed up. The second half  of the song should be psychedelic gold dust, with Ronsons’ s guitar part howling and beguiling, instead it was like watching a brand new Ferrari doing a trip to the local dump- totally wasted.

Not that the first half was  a disaster, “Oh you Pretty things” worked well and was a surprise and welcome inclusion

Act two

Look back in anger

Young Americans

Space oddity

Absolute Beginners

Ashes to Ashes

Fashion

China Girl

Scary Monsters

Suffragette City

Rebel rebel

Lets Dance

Heroes

Modern love

Look back in Anger was a far more sure footed opener, and “Young Americans” and “”Beginners” flourished with original saxophone parts, by contrast “Ashes to Ashes” was destroyed by the saxophone despite the best efforts of John Wilmott on bass.. Fortunately the second act was saved by an energetic “Scary Monsters”  and a whiplash “Suffragette City”.

I have written his for the benefit of the “Bowie fascination” cognoscenti, a party night out crowd would find themselves content, but it was as though they had learned the songs, rather than felt them.

Sound and Vision are touring extensively at the moment.

https://www.facebook.com/soundandvisiontribute/events

Posted in Classic Gigs | Leave a comment

The Legend of Bruce Springsteen Robin 2, Bilston, Wolverhampton, UK 21/7/23

I have been following Springsteen since the Hammersmith Odeon , London shows in 1975.

Hitherto I have resisted  Springsteen tribute shows- until last night. I was nervous. I regard Springsteen as amongst the greatest rock n roll performers ever, the E Street band the greatest bar band.Could they do him justice? The answer proved to be an emphatic yes.

Although Springsteen is now the doyen of Stadium rock, the club setting of the Robin was a perfect fit to showcase where his music has its roots to an enthusiastic Friday night crowd.

Any Springsteen tribute has two big hurdles to overcome. Firstly, his live repertoire contains hundreds of songs including covers going back to the 1960’s. Any setlist will omit dozens of fan favourites.

Secondly,  he would tour with between eight and over a dozen band members. When those costs are underwritten by takings of over £1m a show, as is the case now with Bruce’s stadium shows, that isn’t a problem, when as a tribute act takings are in the several  thousands in small venues the profitability of the project is far tighter.

On the night the setlist was a perfect imperfect combination. The opening “Badlands” took me back to when  I  saw it open the “River” tour, the following “Glory days” has been a live favourite on Bruce’s most recent stadium tour. However it was the early inclusion of “Pink Cadillac” and “Spirits in the Night” which set the standard for the evening revelling in the joy of those early compositions.

One of the things that set the E street band apart when they first broke as  performers was the inclusion of a black frontman saxophonist in the form of the imperious, and irreplaceable Clarence Clemons. He is uncopiable and irreplaceable. “the Legend’s” solution is pure  genius.

 Instead of attempting the impossible they transform the experience by introducing TWO female saxophonists. In the past Robert Palmer and Bryan Ferry have included female saxophonists to great effect.  Here they become the musical, and visual focus of interest, both of whom double up on keyboards. They also provide the fulcrum for the unquestionable highlight of the night, a tumultuous “Jungleland”  featuring a duelling saxophone interlude which was quite breathtaking.

More recent and casual fans were catered for with “Dancing in the Dark”, “Born in the USA” and the inevitable “Born to Run” but other highlights included an elegiac  mournful, doleful “ My Hometown”, a beautifully introspective  “The River”  (“ is a dream a lie if it don’t come true, or is it something worse? “)and a raucous,  rumbustious “The Promised Land” complete with stunning sax break, a song that on release was a song of defiant hope ( “I’ve done my best to live the right way, I get up every morning and go to work each day”), and now, forty years later, it becomes a song of  disappointment, “Blow away the dreams that tear you apart, Blow away the dreams that break your heart,Blow away the lies that leave you nothing but lost and broken hearted ”. The songs continue to touch our souls, but in new ways. “The ghost of Tom Joad” was powerful enough to  supply the National grid.

I have not namechecked individuals because their website does not identify them. They are all superb. The pianist is a delight, how I would love to hear her play on “Racing in the street”, “point Blank” or “prove it all night (78)”.

A wonderful two and a half hours. The band smiled  throughout, the audience smiled and roared back. I will return.

Posted in Classic Gigs | Leave a comment

A Virgin’s Guide to Hiring an Escort, by Lorna Meehan – The Blue Orange Theatre, Birmingham

*****

This is a one woman, one hour performance. The Blue Orange theatre,  a modern, compact space on the fringes of the Jewellery Quarter was perfect. Off beat, and intimate.

An established writer, actor  and performer on the midlands arts circuit, pretty much everything that Lorna  Meehan does is interesting. This is no exception.

Yes the title is an attention grabber, and the content is as the title suggests. If profanity and sex disturb you, the new Barbie film is available as an alternative.

When the show had finished, two words  dominated the exit babble, “brave” and “courageous”. Superficially this is one woman’s monologue reflecting upon her experiences of hiring a male escort, her reasons for doings so, and the fall out. It is also about human desire, and how a failure to acknowledge it can be  all consumingly ,devouringly, self -destructive. It is not didactic, nor is it a cautionary tale. Tales of female prostitution, of the  “Pretty Woman” variety are commonplace, tales of female desire less so  ( Ann Bancroft’ s Mrs Robinson in The Graduate”?) The conventional narrative is turned on its head, the woman wants sex, not the life story of her sexual partner.

At one point, Lorna stuffs a cake into her mouth and swigs from a bottle of wine invoking the  spirit and hedonism of Dionysus and bacchanalia whilst exploring fleshy matters. Dionysus was  the  Greek   god  (amongst many things) of wine-making, of festivity, insanity, ritual madness, religious ecstasy, and theatre. Those who partook of his mysteries were  believed to  have become possessed and empowered by the god himself. But the Roman state treated  popular festivals of Bacchus (Bacchanalia) as subversive, partly because their free mixing of classes and genders transgressed traditional social and moral constraints and  celebration of the Bacchanalia was made a capital offence. The territory which Lorna explores has always been controversial.

Solo performances are always demanding, but Lorna pulls it off with a combination of compelling physical performance and a powerful script written in narrative  verse. So strong are the visuals that I found my brain regularly searching for  the “rewind” switch as couplets and internal rhymes danced by, demanding to be recalled. This piece will be available in both written, and audio book form in due course which will enable her audience to do justice to the smart, sassy and saucy script.

Having lured us in with a salacious title, she manages to get down and dirty with the content without being vulgar, being titillating without the tits! It is also witty and funny.  This is primarily an exploration of intimacy, a subject which crosses the age and gender divide and dares to talk frankly about sex.  The musical interludes ae perfectly chosen, Chris Isaak “Wicked Game” and George Michael’s “Father Figure” amongst them. Director Zak  Marsh excels with a minimalist stage and imaginative props, each of which has to earn their place in Lorna’s hands.

Subversive, innovative and imaginative, Ruby Wax would love to get her hands on this script. See it when it is next performed, buy the book when it comes out. You will not be disappointed.

Posted in Behind the Arras Reviews | Leave a comment

Sucker Punch – Wolverhampton Grand Theatre

This is a revival of a play  by British playwright Roy Williams,  first staged in 2010 at the Royal Court Theatre in London when it was nominated for the Evening Standard Award and the Olivier Award for Best New Play.

Williams himself  was born in Fulham and brought up in Notting Hill, the youngest of four siblings in a single-parent home, with his mother working as a nurse after his father moved to the US. Williams decided to work in theatre after being tutored by the writer Don Kinch when he was failing in school and attended some rehearsals in a black theatrical company Kinch ran. In 1992, he took a theatre-writing degree at Rose Bruford College and has worked ever since as a writer.

I attended the evening with  current Commonwealth boxing light flyweight champion Matt Windle, who lives in the Midlands  as my guest to give me an inside view.

Commonwealth Boxing Champion Matt Windle with myself, Gary Longden

The story is told within a single boxing set in deprived London in the 1980s, with a gym, and ring centre stage ( designer Sandra Falase). Two young black boys, Leon and Troy, are trained by a white trainer, Charlie, who sees their potential. Events unfold against the backdrop of social unrest and racism. The thirteen years since the play was first staged exactly covers the period of a Conservative Government. The social issues covered are no less  relevant now.

The cast of seven features a solitary female,  Becky (Poppy Winter),  Leon’s  would be girlfriend. Winter, in her professional debut,  makes the  very best of her well written role dealing with boys, interracial relationships and an alcoholic, financially hopeless father with considerable skill.

Matt Windle commented , “Gary, boxing is theatre”. He is right. Tragedy,  romance, comedy  success, failure, treachery and revenge are all present in this play which revolves around love. The boxer’s love for their sport, a father’s love for his daughter.

Star of the show is Shem Hamilton as aspiring boxer Leon opposite bad boy friend Troy (  Christian Alifoe). Hamilton convinces as a boxer and love interest for Becky and wrestles with the nuances of his relationship with gym owner and trainer  Charlie ( Liam Smith) admirably.

Charlie forces him to choose between  a relationship with his daughter and a boxing career cleverly framed as white people paying to see black men beat each other up, amongst numerous awkward racial challenges.

Laughter, levity and life are provided by aging Lothario, Squid ( Wayne Rollins)  who plays Leon’s father , a man whose moves are for the bedroom, not the boxing ring.

The script is awash with racial  and sexual slurs, purely there to reflect the time rater than to shock. The unusually diverse audience, of which I would estimate 50% were from the ethnic communities and 80% of that 50% were afro Caribbean m with men and women equally represented, did not take offence, instead roaring laugher.

Closed caption screens were used for the hard of hearing but proved invaluable to follow some of the slang used. The fight sequences were imaginatively handled, often in flash back and slow motion, Asha Jennings-Grant and Enric Ortuño’s work on the movement and fight direction were very effective.

The performed running time is around two hours exclusive of interval in a show which kept everyone engaged winning  deserved rapturous applause at the final curtain. Director Nathan Powell has done a fine job projecting   complex and big issues on a small stage asking what it is to be black in Britain today. Matt Windle confirmed its authenticity and accuracy for the cognoscenti, and felt that racism within boxing and the gyms  was far less a problem today than in the 1980’s, for the rest of us, it was simply a damned good show which tun until Fri 16th at the Grand and continues on tour.

Posted in Behind the Arras Reviews | Leave a comment

The Pretenders- De Montfort hall, Leicester,  Dec 15th 1981

The Pretenders are an odd band.

Their debut album was awash with great songs from the pop/rock tradition even though their genesis was forged on the anvil of punk. Hynde’s career can best be described as mercurial. Arriving from the United states she wrote for NME and quickly inveigled herself into the heart of the burgeoning Punk and new wave scene. Some would call her cynical and calculating, others a creative tour de force. The NME enabled her to mix with the contemporary musical glitterati, her work at SEX put her in with McCLaren and Westwood, he romantic liason with Steve Jones had her alongside the hippest of the upcoming musical talent. Marrying Jim Kerr of simple Minds and Ray Davies of the Kinks ( at separate times obviously)  helped her musical credentials no end. Her debut demo had Phil Taylor of Motorhead on drums, her first single was produced by Nick Lowe. This girl did not appear from nowhere- she worked at it!

At the time of the gig, they had released two albums, the second almost as rich as the first in compositional content with guitarist James Honeyman Scott and bassist Pete Farndon at the heart of the action, not least in providing backing vocals. They were tour tight, on the crest of a wave, and in the vanguard of the new waves’ success. But waves break , in 82 Honeyman scott died, in 83, Farndon died, both from drug abuse. The rock n roll dream had morphed into a nightmare. That should have been it.

Yet no-one should doubt Hyndes’, resilience, her biggest hit to date, “Stop your Sobbing” was a cover of husband Ray Davies hit dissipating royalties.  From somewhere she then conjured up smash hit  “Back on the Chain gang” with whom the only royalties split was with Chambers and she was financially bankrolled for years.

For a young band to have a repertoire of the strength of those first two albums is highly unusual, unsurprisingly they ripped it up at Leicester combining the sexiness of Blondie  with the rock n roll swagger of the Rolling Stones

Highlights, a mesmerising reggae tinged seven minute  “Private life”, by far their greatest song,  a glorious  honeyman scott jingly jangly “kid”and a riveting pulsating closing “Precious” the song the Clash and Ramones would have written if they had a female singer, both songs featuring he indispensable skills of Honeyman Scott and Farndon.

Set List

The Wait

The Adultress

Message of Love

Louie Louie

The English Roses

Stop Your Sobbing

Kid

Private Life

I Go to Sleep

Day After Day

Bad Boys Get Spanked

Up the Neck

Precious

Despite a dearth of material beyond “Chain gang”  hynde has continued to tour successfully to this day, a testament to guts, determination, talent and application.

Posted in Classic Gigs | Leave a comment

PJ Harvey, Hummingbird, Birmingham, 12th May, 1993

I was lucky, I was working away from home, and so had no family commitments in the evening. In a city the size of Birmingham there was always some sort of gig on, and this night I landed on PJ Harvey at the seedy, run down, but glorious Hummingbird in Dale End.

PJ Harvey had come to my attention though John Peel’s evening show, her astonishing debut album and equally astonishing follow up “Rid of me” which she featured that evening.

Her music was as angular and wasted as her appearance, but her performance was emotional, aggressive and defiant, a three piece including  Steve Vaughan  on bass and Rob Ellis – drums, vocals,and  harmonium generating  an extraordinary sound. She reminded me of very early U2 circa their debut album, it is no co-incidence that their manager Danny McGuinness  went on to manage her.

Folk pervades her song writing, she performed a blistering cover of Dylan’s “Highway 61”. The haunting, insistent,  hypnotic  opening “Rid of me”  a superb statement of intent which she struggled to better as the set unfolded, despite the obvious merits of “50ft Queenie” and “Water”. With only two albums worth of material , mostly three minute songs , the set was understandably modest lasting about 75 minutes with no encore, but what she lacked in quantity she generously compensated for with quality. She looked exhausted at the end, and so were we, a performance that was jagged, ragged, lacerating and sexy.

The crowd  was 100% indie and two thirds male despite Polly’s feminist credentials and message. She doesn’t offer the sassiness of Chrissie Hynde or poppiness on Blondie, where she fits I am not entirely sure. What I am sure of is that no female rock performer bettered that night that I had seen or subsequently saw

 -=

Setlist

Rid of Me

Naked Cousin

Primed and Ticking

Highway 61 Revisited

Yuri-G

O Stella

Dress

Wang Dang Doodle

Me-Jane

Victory

Man-Size

Snake

Sheela-Na-Gig

50ft Queenie

Rub ’til It Bleeds

Water

Posted in Classic Gigs | Leave a comment

Around the World in 80 Days – Derby Theatre

***

Six years ago   Derby theatre  performed Laura Easons’ adaptation of this classic story directed by Theresa Heskins .  The 2023 production 150 years on from  the original English publication, is very different and unrecognisable from its previous incarnation , this time directed by  Juliet  Forester for Tilted Wig productions.

Jules Verne’s classic story has obvious cinematic possibilities realised by others in the past, and equally obvious drawbacks as the basis for a stage adaptation. How do you portray a worldwide journey on a theatre stage? Yet that conundrum is also the basis for this dramatic incarnation of the tale. You don’t. You allow the audience’s imagination to do the work. Circus has long been the home of tall stories and impossible feats . Thus Director Juliet Forester  chooses a circus motif and theme to develop the story which is presented to the audience by a group of circus performers as a play within a play. As a novelty she also tells the story   of Nellie Bly, who  travelled around the world in just 72 days.

Sensibly, Forester eschews the problems of depicting eight countries and utilises a single circus set with a roller banner identifying which country the characters were in at any given time . Sara Perks’ split-level  colourful set dominates, its hidden hatch facilitating the best joke of the evening. The see-saw is well used.

The play within a play device allows the circus performers to  engage with younger members of the audience and comment upon the original story and some of its anachronistic elements as well as  using the character of  Nellie Bly to revise the entire premise of the proceedings. Katriona Brown is superb as Bly who somewhat overshadows  Phileas Fogg, played by Alex Phelps.

Wilson Benedito makes the most of classic comic creation Passepartout, the hapless valet.  Eddie Mann steals the show as Detective Fix  attempting to thwart Foggs’ journey and bet, not least in a wild west shoot out which is ingeniously shoe horned into the production. . Foggs’ 80-day trek ends with him finding happiness somewhat closer to home with Aouda ( subtly played by Genevieve) in a schmaltzy denouement which was straight out of the Disney/ Spielberg playbook. Verne hadn’t visited many of the destinations depicted, in the same way that Coleridge  ( Rime of the Ancient Mariner) had never been to sea, but this never impedes a good story.

This is a bold attempt to rework and reinvent a classic story for a modern audience and plays until  Saturday 10th before continuing on nationwide tour.

Gary Longden

Posted in Behind the Arras Reviews | Leave a comment

Absolute Bowie, the Hairy Dog, 19th May, 2023

This was the third Bowie Tribute I have  seen in as many months providing a useful contemporaneous comparison, previously John Mainwaring’s Jean Genie, then Oliver Slee’s Bowie Experience.  I suspect that “better or worse” comes down to the setlist and how that resonate with your own favourite, but Absolute Bowie  are certainly different.

They are  by far the most lavishly costumed. I did not think that would make a difference, but it does, particularly for the first half when the Spiders are dressed as the Spiders. They play as a five piece, John O’Neill as Bowie, Andy Marr on lead guitar as Ronson/ Slick , Varo Sitsi as Wakeman/ Garson on Keys, Sam Ferrari on bass as Bolder, and Alex Face as Woody on drums. As far as I could tell there were no backing tracks, and mercifully no tacky pyrotechnics just a bit of dry ice.

What sets Absolute Bowie apart is the Bowie/ Ronson interplay. I had  forgotten how important that is visually, Marr resplendent in black sequins, platforms and blonde wig- and boy can he play guitar!

They opened with “Let’s Spend the Night Together” which I had never seen performed live before- it works brilliantly and O’Neill uses its refrain  skilfully to connect with the audience. “Ziggy Stardust” is magnificent, but “Moonage Daydream” blows the roof off followed by a rip roaring “Suffragette City” O’Neill establishes a one to one link with the fans as he wails “Keep your electric eye on me babe, put your ray gun to my head” whilst Marr stretches out the solo to provide the standout moment of the night. I am not a fan of swaying my hands in the air, that is best left to a Lionel Richie concert, but for “Dudes” I was swaying them with everyone else, a joyous “Starman” providing a further opportunity for a sing along. The first set closed with a “Life on Mars” which was just a shade bombastic for these ears, sometimes less is more, but was ecstatically received.

The second half opened with the band out of Ziggy Costumes, but with Marr as rock side man Slick and Setsi wearing a jacket as worn by Garson and blasting into “Blue Jean” a bold choice amongst an eclectic  second half set. I have never been a hugs fan of “Fame” live but Marr made it his own with some clever and inventive improvised licks. However the standout song of the second half, vying with “Moonage Daydream” for song of the night, was “ Ashes to Ashes” in which Setsi was given full rein to stretch out then duel at the end with Marr. It was sublime. Garson would have approved.

The second was enhanced by a barnstorming “Look back in Anger” , “China Girl” fell between the Bowie and Iggy versions, “Heroes” did what it needed to,  “ Space oddity “ curiously ended rather than opened the evening and a  400 odd crowd, many of whom had returned after their last Derby show, went home happy.

Absolutely Bowie are unquestionably different. O’Neill embraces Bowie’s sexiness and fey sexual ambivalence and channels Ziggy era Ziggy perfectly, the lavish and on point costumes are an integral part of that. They also visually, and through performance, feature Ronson as an integral part of the show. The same is true of Garson throughout.  Musically they are faultless.

The set list managed to offer some surprises and unpredictability. Anecdotally, many of the fans I spoke to  are fans of the image and hits, not the minutiae of his back catalogue. This traps any Bowie tribute act. With all their money coming from touring, it is the hits which bring the paying punters in, the glorious offbeat obscurities would be commercial suicide for the performing artist.

During “Moonage Daydream” I was transported back to Earls Court in 1973- thank you.

Posted in Behind the Arras Reviews | 2 Comments

Bowie Experience- Lichfield Garrick Theatre, 14/5/23

Two months after the originally scheduled show was postponed  at short notice due to illness,  the “Bowie Experience” appeared to a 500 seat sell out at the Lichfield Garrick Theatre on a Sunday night.

I am a die hard Bowie fan and an enthusiastic consumer of tribute shows.  Tonight intrigued  me. Previously I had seen Laurence Knight fronting the show, who did very well, but for reasons which are not entirely clear to me Oliver Slee has now taken frontman duties. Laurence continues   to tour with a band badged  “The Bowie Experience”, a distinction which many will not identify in advance, and on the night the frequent wig and costume changes   mean that some in the audience may not even realise the frontman  replacement. But that does not matter, as Springsteen once proffered “You have to prove it all night, every night”. To these eyes the original band  seem to have remained in situ apart from a new rhythm guitarist for a cracking evening.

I recently saw John Mainwarings’ long established  “Jean Genie” show and am seeing “Absolute Bowie” in Derby on Friday. The market for Bowie tributes is a given, the challenge they face is becoming harder. The calibre of tribute acts for numerus artists  in terms of presentation, production, performance and musicianship is improving all the time, audience expectation is rising. The sceptre of Abba’s “Voyager” show has also changed everything. A virtual performance by a band captured in their heyday takes some beating.

Oliver Slee a Bournemouth actor and drama teacher, is 26 years old, the same age  as Ziggy era Bowie enjoying a similar lean physique and frontaas Bowie. “Space Oddity” is an apposite opener. Vocally it is not too stretching, but musically it gives  the band a chance to stretch their muscles. As it draws to a close, we all know that everything is going to be alright.

They do use some backing tracks, most notably on “Life on Mars” adding orchestration, but the eight piece ( Slee on vocals and occasional guitar), lead and rhythm guitar, keyboards, bass, drums and two backing singes one of whom plays saxophone, the other a multi instrumentalist make a pretty hefty sound in their own right.

First half

Space Oddity

Queen Bitch

Changes

Life on Mars

Moonage daydream

Ziggy

Man Who Sold the World

Sorrow

John I’m Only dancing

Jean Genie

Suffragette CIty

Rebel Rebel

Second Half

Diamond Dogs

Cracked Actor

Station to Station

Young Americans

Sound n vision

Boys keep Swinging

Fashion

Lets Dance

China girl

Under Pressure

Heroes

All the Young Dudes

The first half is Ziggy era culminating in a rousing “Rebel Rebel” and the amusing sight of a predominantly sixty something audience enthusiastically yelling the chorus. It also reminds you how THAT riff, alongside “jumping Jack Flash”, “Sweet Home Alabama” ,”Don’t Fear the Reaper” “Whole lotta love and “Smoke on the water” is locked into our collective subconscious waiting to explode as soon as those chiming notes ring out.

The surprise highlight was a sublime slowed down waltz paced “Sorrow” segueing into an euphoric “John I’m Only Dancing” cheekily introduced  by borrowing Queen’s  Crazy little Thing called Love” intro. A song that on vinyl struggled to find a home on stage found just that with this spot.

Musical director and lead guitarist Tim Wedlake had a few more surprises up his sleeve too.

In the second half I am always wary of Station to Station being used in any other set position that is not opener. But here, a slightly edited version segues  magnificently into “Golden Years” as the second half. It worked brilliantly. “Ashes to Ashes” is given a reggae intro ( which begged for a “Don’t look Back” sample which didn’t come”), “Boys keep Swinging” goes full rock and “Under Pressure” a song I don’t like, becomes a show highlight with backing singer, and multi-instrumentalist Charlotte Talbot, all glam in a black evening dress with mesh sleeves, taking centre stage for the duet, the song soars.

“China Girl”  performed by Iggy Pop is dark and dirty as envisioned by Nile Rodgers it is light and poppy. Wedlake reinvents it once again as a stretched out hybrid of the two, it was wonderfully realised.

The home straight of Heroes and “Dudes” was euphoric stuff with the crowd baying for more but Slee confessing they had nothing further rehearsed which was  a shame – it cried out for “Rock n Roll Suicide”. Ssaxophonist Westwood was a vital ingredient, her concession to costume change was to chnage from black pvc leggings into black tights for the second half!

With tribute shows it is easy to look for trouble, but the fact is that the band delivered a popular hits heavy set which the audience lapped up with arrangements which were skilful and much helped by five part vocal harmonies, saxophonist Emily Westwood dovetailing nicely with Talbot.

Posted in Behind the Arras Reviews | Leave a comment

John Mainwaring as “The Jean Genie” – the Flowerpot PH, Derby.

Tribute acts continue to be a contentious subject  on this site. I had seen The Jean Genie fifteen years ago and had enjoyed his show very much, but I was intrigued to discover what my reaction would be now in a tribute market which has been transformed in recent years.

Two things have changed . Firstly the quality of the show, calibre of the act, and performance, have improved immeasurably to the point where they are now touring  playing theatres ( and in the Australian Pink Floyds case Arenas). Secondly , Abba’s  virtual Voyage show has revolutionised what a Tribute show can be.

So, who is “The Jean Genie” ? He  was created by John Mainwaring  in 1993. An original recording artist in his own right, John Mainwaring had been signed by numerous record companies throughout his career – twice with Warner Bros. In the 1980s  Tony Visconti produced some of John’s songs when he was signed to WEA.

John has worked with  with Jarvis Cocker on his ‘Bad Cover Version’ single, singing and starring in the video, and recorded all the music for Beverley Callard’s (  aka Liz McDonald in Coronation St)  work-out fitness DVD entitled ‘Lasting Results’. As well as performing as David Bowie in Jean Genie, John is currently signed to Bucks Music Publishers. He wrote 3 songs for Tony Christie’s million selling album ‘The Definitive Collection’, plus numerous theme tunes for BBC radio.

In the late 1990s John was approached by  ‘The Spiders from Mars’  to tour with them, which he did. John remains to this day to be one of only a few tribute artists to tour and perform with that  original artist’s band.  He has been a regular fixture   with Trevor Chance’s  show of ‘Legends’ in Blackpool.

His credentials are fine, but how would he do in this celebrated, wonderfully cramped, sold out music venue in Derby on an Easter Saturday night ?

I had forgotten what a gregarious and friendly crowd Bowie fans are with pre gig drinks a whirl of reminiscences with new acquaintances.

As the house lights dimmed the band sauntered on stage to an electronic reworking of “Ode to Joy” , a nice nod to  Ziggy era Bowie shows. No costumes, no look  alikes, with John dressed in a dinner jacket the only concessions to razzmatazz  being a few puffs of dry ice and guitarist Steve Gardiners handsome  Gibson. They perform as a three piece, drums, bass, electric guitar and John on occasional acoustic guitar.

 There were some very discreet backing tracks with keyboards. This comes with advantages and disadvantages. The advantage  is that, particularly in the first hal,f the vibe of an early  Spiders show was conjured up very persuasively. The disadvantage is that  some songs sans overt keys suffered, as did the fullness of the sound. But in the real world, touring with another musician takes another chunk of  door revenue and they got away with it, just, mainly because of the musical dexterity  of the band.

The show was divided into two halves, the first half was resolutely Ziggy era Bowie plus the welcome addition of  a very good “Valentine’s Day”

Five years

Changes

The Man who sold the world

Space oddity

Queen bitch

Suffragette city

Valentines day

Moonage daydream

Starman

The second half was an eclectic  Bowie smorgasbord, bravely opening and closing with two of David’s most vocally demanding songs.

Wild is the Wind

Medley including Dancing in the street/ Sound n Vision/ Boys/ Fashion/ Ashes  various

Jean genie

Heroes

Lets dance

Life on Mars

encores

Rebel Rebel

Ziggy

Early on John declared that the show was simply about keeping Bowie’s music alive, and playing it properly. You could not fault the musicianship, and the clever arrangements to compensate for the limited on stage instrumentation were superb. That success was almost entirely due to the real star of the show, Steve Gardiner and his Gibson Les Paul Gold Top.

Steve looks every inch the classic rock star with his lithe frame and flowing long hair, the perfect Ronson doppelganger. A very accomplished guitarist, he switched effortlessly from Robert Fripp’s parts in Heroes, to Stevie Ray Vaughan’s in lets dance. He also squeezed every second of drama out of “Moonage Daydream” and a raucous “suffragette City”.

Presenting Bowie songs  is the greatest challenge for any Bowie tribute. David’s arrangements , vocal style and fashion changed over his forty years of live performance, it is an insurmountable task for any one person. John sings them pretty straight, with Gardiner and bassist Dan  Clark singing occasional harmony vocals. Frustratingly these were oddly absent during “Moonage Daydream”, ”Ashes to Ashes” and some others. John eschewed  David’s reflective original delivery  of “Heroes” opting boldly for the bombastic post 9/11 version.

A special mention is due bassist Dan Clark, who in the absence of a keyboard or electric rhythm guitarist had to work doubly hard to fill out the live sound- he did so admirably, to a rock steady drumbeat.

It would be true say that the medley section divided opinion in the crowd post gig. It enabled extra songs to be shoehorned into the set, but was a bizarre Jive Bunny/ Stars on45 hybrid, however I accepted John’s ill judged  affected take on “Dancing in the street”  as a price worth paying for a superbly reworked “Sound and Vision”.

Overall it was a hugely enjoyable evening, much appreciated by a knowledgeable, discerning and enthusiastic Saturday night crowd at a great live venue. . A touching and unexpected highlight was when the volume naturally dipped during “Ashes to ashes” enabling the entire crowd to be heard singing; “I’ve never done good things, I’ve never done bad things, I’ve never done anything out of the blue-whoa”. Live magic.

Posted in Classic Gigs | Leave a comment