City of God

Visceral Brilliance, 3 April 2009

Author: gary-444 from United Kingdom

A wonderful film that succeeds in paying homage to the American gangster film genre whilst at the same time creating a distinct world all of its own.An unknown cast is brilliantly Directed by Fernando Meirelles to offer a stunning insight into the world of the slums in Brazil, and in particular The City of God.

Although telling the story over the decades of a group of slum children, and concentrating on one who made good, and another who made very bad,an Everyman story also emerges of poverty, survival and quick wits.The stunning Cinematography contrasts sharply with the grimy tale that unfolds told almost exclusively through the eyes of the young protagonists.

A body count unfolds which would make Tarantino blush, and we quickly become desensitised to the casual deaths, often of children.Yet a richness of spirit emerges which , helped by some gallows humour, keeps the story bounding along at a brisk pace.few films justify a 130 minute running time, this does.Told in episodic fashion each section is produced in a highly disciplined manner.With little in the way of special effects the narrative has to triumph, and it does.A particularly noticeable feature is that unlike in Hollywood, when rounds are fired, people are shot, and stay shot.

A foreign language tour de force.

Posted in Films | Leave a comment

The Damned United

Damned Brilliant, 29 March 2009

Author: gary-444 from United Kingdom

Football has been poorly served by the cinema to date. “The Damned United” goes a long way to rectifying that. A bravura performance from Martin Sheen as Brian Clough and a faithful, intelligent screenplay by Peter Morgan combine with a well chosen storyline to deliver a convincing tale. Crucially, this is not a film about football, it uses football as a framework for ambition, greed, success, failure, friendship and love.

The traditional traps surrounding a football film are avoided. “Live” action is limited, and team sequences brief. Consequently the characters are given a chance to breathe and develop , not just Clough’s, but those of Peter Taylor, marvellously captured by Timothy Spall, and others . Chairmen Manny Cousins and Sam Longson enjoy rewarding cameo parts and the footballers themselves are picked as actors rather than surrogate footballers.

Critics may carp about the odd anachronism and unconvincing physical shape of the Leeds United team in particular but it is the ego of Brian Clough which bestrides this story. The 90 minutes barely does justice to his 45 days at Leeds as his career up to the appointment is interwoven into the main tale. Although faction is a dangerous device, for me it does justice to both the lovingly recreated era and the characters. Cloughs family have apparently repudiated this work, which is a shame. It is broadly favourable with the wrinkles as foibles rather than damnable weaknesses.

The film closes with a re-creation of the YTV interview with Clough and Revie sitting side by side immediately following Clough’s dismissal. The atmosphere is electric, Clough is surprisingly conciliatory whilst Revie delivers an, “I told you so”, tour de force. Echoes of the Sheen/Morgan collaboration Frost / Nixon abound as does the repeated device of the late night telephone call from the arch protagonists, this time Clough to Revie, last time Nixon to Frost. The final reconciliation between Clough and Taylor is as brave a depiction of a male platonic relationship as has been screened for a very long time.

A triumph for all concerned

Posted in Films | Leave a comment

Knowing

Leave Before The End, 29 March 2009

Author: gary-444 from United Kingdom

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

The basic ingredients for this film are all here, a fine Big Budget Director (Alex “I Robot” Proyas), Big Name Leading Man,Nicholas Cage, the guts of a good story, and lots and lots of money. Sadly, it is holed below the waterline with one of the worst endings I have seen in Cinematic History, a view shared by virtually everyone whom I know who has seen this film.The relatively interesting plot also suffers prolonged assault from a very poor script offering trite, clichéd mechanical dialogue.

Recovering a 50 year old time capsule from an Elementary School is a promising enough start. Child actor Chandler Canterbury , as Caleb Koestler has a father who is an University Professor schooled in Random and Determinist Theory, who has a friend who is an Astro- Physicist. When Caleb is given a 50 year old list from the time capsule it is not difficult to guess where this story is heading. Disasters are both foretold, and anticipated and their place in them becomes central to the plot.

A plane and subway crash,separately, are brilliantly realised in two of the most compelling disaster sequences I have seen, these two items alone score 6/10 for the film. The exact denouement is reasonably concealed, but whenrevealed is preposterous, absurd, risible and excruciatingly realised.

Out of nowhere an ET moment occurs so sickly sweet and devoid of credibility and tension that all before it is destroyed. Why Caleb doesn’t cry to his Dad ,”This spaceship is really cool, I’m going on board to take a look,” is beyond me. We then have a hugely impressive, and pointless, “Day After Tomorrow,” sequence as New York is wiped out AGAIN ( this City must have some bad movie karma).The closing frames of children holding hands, on a mythical planet, clutching cuddly rabbits as waving wheat and barley sweep around them in a verdant valley, complete with the Tree of Life is about as ill-advised as it gets.

If the studio had halved the budget, a credible ending and script might have emerged. Instead we get lazy, bloated Hollywood at its very worst. I await the DVD release purely to see if there is an alternate ending. Otherwise, enjoy a reasonable enough effort – and leave 20 minutes before the end. You will feel much better for it.

Posted in Films | Leave a comment

Duplicity

Conned, 24 March 2009

Author: gary-444 from United Kingdom

I was lured to see this on the promise of a smart, witty slice of old fashioned fun and intrigue – I was conned. A knowing, pretentious, tedious, overlong story which suffocates under its own artifice. Starring Julia Roberts ( Claire Stenwick) ,and Clive Owen (Ray Koval), as “Duplicitous” spies, the film tries to recreate the glitter, froth and intrigue of roles made famous by the likes of Cary Grant in the 1950’s, yet fails under leaden direction and total lack of chemistry between the leads.

Director “Michael Clayton” Tony Gilroy also has writing credits for The Bourne series, so his credentials are excellent. But Clive Owen seems ill at ease as a romantic, witty lead apparently yearning for the opportunity to play the more robust part he played in the under rated “International”. Julia Roberts shines in one of her better performances, offering more than her obvious glamour but without the quality of script to enable her to truly excel. She seems barely bothered about enticing Owen into bed, and the word play between them consistently falls flat.

An extensive travelogue incorporating London, Rome, New York, Dubai and Geneva provides some scenic interest, as these erstwhile CIA and MI6 spies swap political espionage for industrial espionage turning into criminal espionage. At 126 minutes it is at least 35 minutes too long. Sharper editing, greater pace, and less “flab” might have made this a better picture. But we are left with it as it is, an instantly disposable, and forgettable addition to the respective parties film credits

Posted in Films | Leave a comment

Surveillance

Frustratingly Average, 12 March 2009

Author: gary-444 from United Kingdom

This is far better than Director Jennifer Lynch’s debut “Boxing Helena” Yet it still fails to excel in any of the genre’s it explores. A good cast acquit themselves well with cinematography which is both easy on the eye when it needs to be, and visceral when required. Exactly what role father and executive Producer played is a mystery but the trade mark off-beat quirky David Lynch style ingredients do not fire on all cylinders.

As a straightforward murder/mystery with a twist it is fine. As a thriller it lacks pace, and as a torture/horror piece it fails despite some graphic, gory moments. The Coen brothers in “No Country For Old Men” understand that it is the threat of violence which can be so unsettling. Here, it is neither under stated enough for aesthetes, nor consistently gory enough for “carnage” fans.

At just over 90 minutes the story stays within its welcome. Told in flashback to “surveillance ” cameras, the device works and is well constructed. The plot twist works insofar as it delivers a dramatic “gear change” to the story, but it also raises numerous loose ends which tend to irritate , rather than delight. Ultimately routine fare, but with enough promise to secure another film offer for Jennifer, I suspect

Posted in Films | Leave a comment

Gran Torino

Eastwood, actor and director, on superb form, 6 March 2009

Author: gary-444 from United Kingdom

A superb piece of cinema which sees Eastwood scale new heights as both Director, and Actor. I have never given a film a maximum rating before, as the very essence of art is striving for that little bit more. But not to do so for a work that so conspicuously accomplishes its lofty objectives would be churlish indeed.

The story is simple enough, just widowed Walter Kowalski, a Korean War veteran is becoming increasingly isolated. His wife has died, the world is changing all around him, and his neighbourhood is dominated by South East Asians, some of whom have moved in next door. Yet mistrust gives way to acceptance which turns to friendship as Walter fights one last battle with those that threaten his sense of values.

It is hard to watch Walter Kowalski without seeing virtually every character that Eastwood has ever played, and in part, he is a distillation of them all. Sometimes he doesn’t talk at all, just emitting a Bear like growl, of anger? Of pain? Or maybe both. In part this is an elegiac, valedictory paean to the American Dream, embodied by his eponymous “Gran Torino”. The American motor car holds an iconic place in U.S. popular culture as lauded by the Beach Boys, Bruce Springsteen and Jack Kerouac, so when next door neighbour Tao is forced to try to steal it as part of a Gang Initiation, this is more than an attempted car theft. This is an assault on the very essence of what ex-Ford car worker Walter holds dear.

Yet it draws him into a culture which whilst ostensibly alien, he comes to realise holds dear values which he has considered lost. Family duty and service are paramount. Whilst his own son sells Japanese cars, his grand daughter has her own eyes on the Gran Torino, and the family are circling the Estate like vultures. The irony that the Polish immigrant antecedents of a name like Kowalski are testament to a previous generation’s assimilation and adaptation of the American dream resonates throughout.

Pushing 80 years old now, actor Eastwood wisely eschews an overtly “hard man” role, yet in that icy stare lies not only the fictional quintessentially American blue collar views of veteran and production line worker, but also the ghosts of Dirty Harry and a plethora of Western vengeance seekers, and wreakers. The violence, such as it is, is understated. The depiction of the Mong gangs, restrained. Ever since the stylised teenage gang violence of West Side Story morphed into the gratuitous excesses of “Death Wish”, American cinema has glamorised and celebrated this phenomena in shameless supplication to a teenage audience. Not here it isn’t.

Director Eastwood has produced his finest hour here. Not a single frame is wasted. The American flag flutters behind him as he sits on his porch, dog by his side, early in the film viewing the wholly alien customs and language of his next door neighbours. The dialogue is similarly efficient. Elegaic, without being sentimental, Eastwood’s trademark wry humour is also evident as he tries to introduce “man talk” to Tao, in his Italian hairdressers, and in his ongoing duels with a Priest a third of his age, keen to speak to him about matters ” life and death”.

There is an excellent supporting cast, lead by Ahney Her, as Sue who provides a linguistic and dramatic bridge between Kowalski and the surrounding community. If this is Eastwood’s swansong as a leading role actor it is a fitting one. However I do hope that his Directorial ambitions remain. As an actor popular acclaim superseded critical acclaim resulting in his fairly late entry into the Directors chair. On this form he still has much more to give 

Posted in Films | Leave a comment

New In Town

Light Pleasant Fare, 6 March 2009

Author: gary-444 from United Kingdom

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

How you rate this film depends upon the benchmark you are using. On the one hand there is nothing exceptional about it, it excels at nothing. This is Director Jonas Elmer’s first major feature – and he and the studio take no chances. On the other, as a light romantic comedy, clinging for dear life to a tried and tested formula, it is enjoyable and executes its task perfectly well.

The plot synopsis is very straight forwards. City high flyer Lucy Hill ,played by Renee Zellweger is sent to backwater Minesota to “downsize” and ultimately close a food production plant. Upon arrival the locals amuse themselves with her unfamiliarity with local ways. She falls in love with her nemesis , Harry Connick Jnr as Ted Williams the Union representative, is won over by the town’s quirky charm, saves the Plant from closure and everyone lives happily ever after.

A number of scenes, notably the hunting one, are genuinely funny, and the various town characters are affectionately and warmly played. The merits of the simple family life are a cornerstone of the films values, as much as the, “cold weather but warm people symbolism.” But Zellweger is fine ,though Harry Connick Jnr struggles to convince as her love interest in an under written role. Her high heels will have women green with envy, and set men’s pulses racing. The slight story at 97 minutes is probably 10 minutes too long. But the feel good schmaltzy ending will send devotees, and the casuals,home perfectly content

Posted in Films | Leave a comment

The International

Bank Thriller Holds Interest, 3 March 2009

Author: gary-444 from United Kingdom

*** This review may contain spoilers ***

A contemporary thriller featuring a corrupt bank, and the execution of banking officials, certainly scores on topicality. Overall, this attempt to deal with international terrorism, money laundering, fraud and geo-political power plays is quite enjoyable. One of the problems with financial misdeeds is that on screen, it is boring, and lacks dramatic impact. Director Tom Tykwer overcomes this by having people executed at regular intervals, and mixing it with the odd shoot out to pump up the action quotient.

Lead actor Clive Owen as international agent Louis Salinger is a serviceable enough action hero, Naomi Watts as his boss Eleanor Whitman though is totally miscast and lightweight. To his credit , Tykwer keeps the two hour running time ticking along, the drawback is that it is by a series of clichés and formulaic plot devices. You are never kept guessing as the plot unfolds.

Bank raids are exciting. Corporate plots to indebt third world country’s are not. However a big budget allows the action to shuttle between Berlin, Luxembourg, Italy, New York and Istanbul, pretty much evenly divided enabling a scenic shift alone to create some new interest. But for every bit of cerebral intrigue, we are “rewarded” with routine action fare. Watts is run over, which hurts, but seems none the worse for her ordeal. A “Jackal style” execution scene is handled with the sophistication that Frederick Forsyth could muster on the back of a business card, and a shoot -out in the Guggenheim Gallery in New York is so over-blown it could have been Rambo taking on all-comers in a firestorm of automatic weapon fire.

The climax is pure James Bond. And like Bond, so long as you don’t pay too much attention to the detail, it does it’s job pretty well without excelling either as an action movie, or densely plotted thriller

Posted in Films | Leave a comment

Rescue Dawn

A Disappointing Derivative Effort, 1 March 2009

Author: gary-444 from United Kingdom

I am a fan of war movies in general,Vietnam War Movies in particular, and Herzog as a Director, with “Fitzcarraldo” still one of the most astonishing pieces of film making I have ever seen.So this film should have been an obvious one for me to enjoy, but it wasn’t.The production values, unsurprisingly, are excellent, and Christian Bale takes the lead role well, but as an entity it failed for me.

Despite the efforts of Bale,as pilot Dietar Dengler, the running time of 126 minutes feels long.The pre-capture scenes on the aircrtaft carrier, and the post rescue scenes have the Patriotic,jingoistic feel of “Bat21” or “Mising in Action”, which is fine, but the tone sits ill at ease with the more reflective mood of the time in the jungle.

The UK 12 certification gives Herzog little room for manoeuvre in showing the interrogation, torture and captivity of Dengler and others in a realistic light.Unsurprisingly the film lifts in scenes which contain only the beautiful jungle, and an escaping Dengler, where survival and rescue are paramount.But the long sequences wear thin and without the bravado of the “Bat21/MIA” ideology to sustain the momentum it starts to run a little flat.

Wholly overlooked is the sheer bravery and fortitude of the Laotian people, thrown into a secret war that was not of their choice.The Laotian/NVA characters are largely cyphers with no substance, which is a shame.A noble hunter AND quarry always increases the dramatic possibilities.

In summary this story tries to pander to too many tastes, and ends up short in all genres.it is not gung ho enough for the “USA Defender of Right” brigade,it is too sanitised for the “Vietnam sceptic” lobby.the beginning and end will irritate the hell out of the “Herzog purist” fans

and genre specific afficianados will struggle to get satisfaction form the incomplete elements of the several genres contained.

A good looking, but unsatisfying effort 

Posted in Films | Leave a comment

St Trinians

Fun, Frothy Entertainment., 28 February 2009

Author: gary-444 from United Kingdom

The original St Trinians series was a classic of it’s era, well acted, well written and very funny.Whilst probably falling short of the standards of it’s inspiration, it is nonetheless amusing, entertaining and modern.And perhaps that is also it’s strength, it borrows from the original without copying it, and the modern incarnation provides sufficient distance for it to be considered on its own merits.

Rupert Everett is superb as the School Headmistress, although the likeness to television personality Esther Rantzen is unnerving.Russell Brand demonstrates that his comic talents flourish even better under direction and a script than with the free form of stand-up comedy, as the “spiv”.Stephen Fry is perfect as a quiz show host, and Colin Firth plays the straight man fall guy with some aplomb. All in all a very good cast.

The 100 minute running time is just right. the editing and script is quick with plenty of one liners and visual jokes to watch out for.Though not a work of comic genius this will appeal both to schoolchildren unfamiliar with the original, and parents who are and remember the original with fondness.I would certainly happily see a sequel.

Posted in Films | Leave a comment